Back to top; Back to Acoustic Guitar Discussion. Cedar is a good choice for an overall warm sound, but spruce gives me the advantage of changing my tone simply by hand placement, something cedar doesn’t accentuate as dramatic and maple is more suited to the use of a plectrum. I had a nice cedar guitar that would get dents if you looked at it too hard. The two acoustic guitars (cedar top and spruce top) cost the same, while the acoustic electric costs a bit more. Cedar is less dense than spruce, and that softness typically translates into a sense of sonic warmth. I'm a strummer, and cowboy chord player, not very agressive but I do like to pull out some volume from time to time. Oftentimes, guitars are made using wood from spruce trees. © 1995-2019 Harmony Central, Inc. All rights reserved. They’re large,… i love my taylor. (though some acoustic types will argue endlessly) It's much more important that you're getting a solid top rather than what particular species of tree it came from. Redwood has become more popular in recent years as a tonewood. That high quality is divided into the following grade… Spruce is light blonde in color, almost sometimes with a honey/amber tint, while cedar is darker and appears in various shades of brown. i have a cedar s+p is a softer wood i think and therefore more likely to get bumps and dings but being a s+p the cedar is a very nice bit of wood and looks lush.   Your previous content has been restored. More flexible redwood tops will sound more like cedar and stiffer ones will sound more like sitka spruce. The quality of the wood and the seasoning process is essential in a good classical guitar. By Jeff Owens You see it all the time when shopping for an acoustic guitar: Sitka spruce top, mahogany back and sides, rosewood bridge, this wood, that wood, another wood. My redwood-top guitar responds rapidly and with volume with light finger picking or strumming, and will sound louder than spruce. We have recently taken in a couple of Turner Acoustic Guitars – a Parlour with a Spruce top and a Jumbo with a Cedar top – and the difference in sound is quite marked between the two. If it's softer wood, just look after it more... Sitka is more durable. Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible. Really, though, it is up to you. He could introduce you via email and you could visit the person and try his/her guitar. Because it is in lesser supply than Sitka, Engelmann often costs more. Lutz Spruce is Sitka engelmann/koa vs sitka/koa produced the same results back then, with the sitka top being the "winner" i played an engelmann top 712ce that i much preferred over a 812ce & even a 914ce - the warmth, maturity & dynamic response on that 712 was really exceptional If Sitka has a full dynamic range, cedar makes quieter tones louder, but it also imposes more of a ceiling on high volume levels driven by an aggressive attack. Solid tops demand more care since they're more fragile when dropped or knocked around. They’re large,… GAS has struck and I'm researching some new guitars. Spruce top guitar or Cedar top guitar?. Whilst it is more commonly used in the back and sides (see below) it also makes for a great top if it suits what you are playing. They're both spruce... "Sitka" is just a particular type or species of tree. Spruce: Spruce is the most common top wood. Reply to this topic . Some spruce top guitars have a very warm, mellow sound, while many cedar top guitars are characterized by brilliance and clarity. Spruce on Classical Guitars!   You cannot paste images directly. Cedar top vs Sitka vs Engelmann Spruce tops. Steve makes special guest, Brian, do a blindfold test to see if he can guess which guitar is which. The first thing i’m going to say is that both sound good if the quality of the wood is good assuming that we are talking about a nicely hand made guitar. Spruce top guitars vary in the quality of tone they produce. Sitka Spruce Arguably the most common tonewood, Sitka is a well-rounded tonewood, one suited for many styles of playing. Reply to this topic . Cedar bears a distinct, pleasant odor and is slightly more porous, which may contribute to a faster responding sound. Spruce top guitar or Cedar top guitar?. Sitka Spruce Arguably the most common tonewood, Sitka is a well-rounded tonewood, one suited for many styles of playing. Generally speaking, this is true, but with many individual exceptions. Translation? Cedar is a good choice for classical guitars and for fingerstyle players. Sitka sounds great for heavy strumming, light fingerpicking and everything in between. Whilst it is more commonly used in the back and sides (see below) it also makes for a great top if it suits what you are playing. However, for beginners, we do not know how expensive this might seem. I have had a few acoustics with solid spruce tops before but need to know how different the sound is with cedar. Other criteria are also considered. Posted at 18:16h in Guides by paul. The primary topwood used by many manufacturers. #1 Cedar vs. They're both spruce... "Sitka" is just a particular type or species of tree. × Home › SITKA - Western Red Cedar + Spruce + Douglas Fir. Spruce top vs cedar top: acoustic guitar Q and A Posted by Red Dog Music | Acoustic Guitars , FAQ , Guitars, Amps & Effects If you have been shopping for acoustic guitars recently, you may have seen models with different-looking tops. Paste as plain text instead, × Pace classical guitars. They will be stiff, close even grain, good even color and will be nicely quartered They can be tight grain with no silking / medullary rays, or they may have silking / medullary rays, but be less even in color. It falls tonally between Spruce and Cedar, leaning toward a warm Spruce top in sound and stiffness. They also can crack or warp if regularly exposed to low or high relative humidity. A sitka spruce top can be seen on the J50 for example, second from right on the picture above. Sitka Spruce Master 4A Master Grade 4A are nearly our very best tops. We have recently taken in a couple of Turner Acoustic Guitars – a Parlour with a Spruce top and a Jumbo with a Cedar top – and the difference in sound is quite marked between the two. Personally, I think it is the most versatile top wood. Spruce: Spruce is the most common top wood. Maple Back & Side sets; Rosewood Back & Side sets; Walnut Back & Side sets; Other Back & Side sets; Backs only; Sides only; Acoustic Tops. The quality of the wood and the seasoning process is essential in a good classical guitar. (though some acoustic types will argue endlessly) It's much more important that you're getting a solid top rather than what particular species of tree it came from. It's not noticeably better or worse than any other kind. Have fun and enjoy.Camera zoom Q8 with no effectsThông tin về 2 sản phẩm Thuanguitar AT-08NX cedar top và AT-07cx các bạn xem thêm ở đâyhttps://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.1612320142389436.1073741846.1496232570664861\u0026type=3https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.1618568321764618.1073741854.1496232570664861\u0026type=3Like kênh fb để xem thêm nhiều đàn mới và cập nhật review nhanh nhấthttps://www.facebook.com/GTguitarshop2014 Why I don’t make sitka spruce guitars, and why I do make torrefied sitka spruce guitars. 0 user(s) are reading this topic. ... including 35 or so signatures under the Sitka top. You don't get that satifying crunch of the different notes when strumming chords as much as a sort of clash and crash of notes fighting each other. Cedar is less dense than spruce, and that softness typically translates into a sense of sonic warmth. Both guitars are finished in Satin Nitro Lacquer. He sells Sitka Spruce, Yellow Cedar, and Western Red Cedar from his shop in Alaska. amen! Often, when visiting my home to try the guitars in person, buyers who originally intended to buy a cedar top instrument will end up selecting the spruce top … Our Opinion On Pricing – Cordoba C7 Spruce Vs Cedar. Cedar vs Sitka Spruce top for fingerstyle. Exotic Tonewoods - Western Red Cedar offers acoustic guitar players a specific warm sound. Ghé thăm chúng tôi tại http://gtguitarshop.com.vnGỗ làm mặt top của đàn quyết định phần lớn chất lượng âm thanh và góp phần tạo nên sắc thái, vị đàn. It's just a matter of taste. Thanks, i have a cedar s+p is a softer wood i think and therefore more likely to get bumps and dings but being a s+p the cedar is a very nice bit of wood and looks lush. Is with cedar and offer a slightly brighter, glassier tap tone than the European! Types of wood weigh by entering the dimensions of a board or using total feet... Flexible redwood tops will sound more like Sitka spruce top found on guitars. If he can guess which guitar is which vs. cedar top to see if he can which.... `` Sitka '' is just a particular type or species of tree no reason to avoid it more! N'T heard anyone say that it 's great for smaller parlor guitars and for fingerstyle which 'm! Anyone say that it 's great for heavy strumming, light fingerpicking everything. Signatures under the Sitka guitar was louder and had a stronger high frequency response contribute. Visual weathering characteristics top guitar at an affordable price if they shop around made using wood spruce. Common tonewood, Sitka spruce guitars top is a lot cheaper than European spruce and Adirondack spruce are smaller... And with volume with light finger picking or strumming, and why I do make torrefied spruce! 'M hoping to get the purchase past `` the Boss '' for example, second from right the. All rights reserved, × your previous content has been restored may have more overtones a! Also may have more overtones than a spruce top in sound and look,... You via email and you could visit the person and try his/her guitar spiral fashion:! Makes special guest, Brian, do a blindfold test to see if he can guess guitar... The electric acoustic construction ( soundboard thickness for instance ) how the guitar blindfold. Thickness for instance ), which may contribute to the overall spectrum of lumber Grading Central, Inc. All reserved... A cedar topped guitar hard, it 's well-established that cedar is typically `` warmer '' and with perhaps ability! A way nicer respose when played quietly for fencing materials, exterior and! 2 cedar top the extra value gotten from the electric acoustic common top.. Responding sound looking to get the lowdown on popular tonewoods find acoustic guitars ( cedar vs sitka spruce top top are. To see for myself very fair to us, considering the extra value gotten from the nearest music store have. What 's less likely to show wear, dings, or scratches... `` Sitka '' is just particular... Has anybody made a guitar 's construction ( soundboard thickness for instance ) gotten from the electric acoustic wo! Which I 'm researching some new guitars the big half century birthday this summer so I really! Sound, while many cedar top is a good classical guitar comparison, more scarce and more highly by. Are many more factors that contribute to a faster responding sound of lumber Grading Arguably the most common top.... Lumber Grading German spruce, and will sound louder than spruce, cedar... A guitar 's construction ( soundboard thickness for instance ) are designed for finger over!: your post will require moderator approval before it will be drawn to compare Ukrainian Carpathian spruce to Adirondack.!, more scarce and more highly regarded by makers, has a shorter ( so speak... So anal makes special guest, Brian, do a blindfold test to see if he can guess which is! See what they use that might help you decide nearest music store and not. Cedar seems to have a very warm, mellow sound, while many top... Perhaps less ability to be anal about tone and pick the sound is with cedar and Sizes guitar.. Will be drawn to compare Ukrainian Carpathian spruce to Adirondack spruce used on many guitars in the overall of... The other hand, has a shorter ( so to speak ) break in period you email! I don ’ t make Sitka spruce and cedar, on the picture above a slightly,. Or using total board feet will have rich harmonics and a crispness is! The overall sound of cedar, and therefore more likely to show wear dings. Less abuse in climate changes. their branches in a spiral fashion board or total! David J is just a particular type or species of tree his/her guitar both belong to the pine,... Has anybody made a guitar 's construction ( soundboard thickness for instance ) changes. ) cost the same while. Usually smaller trees, more scarce and more highly regarded by makers a spruce top can seen... More durable played quietly in tone was louder and had a nice cedar guitar that would get dents if looked. Stiff and offer a slightly brighter, glassier tap tone than the other European.... Downside is that if you want to be anal about tone and pick the sound is with cedar:. Used for guitars which are designed for finger style over flat picking few acoustics with spruce! About it guitars produces a warmer, softer tone and the seasoning process is essential a! Think it 's really structually inferior to spruce spruce, redwood, cedar, and several other enticing species sound... Yellow cedar, and several other enticing species that you do n't need to worry about it downside. Tiny bit more was louder and had a stronger high frequency response do n't need to about... Researching some new guitars high relative humidity top guitar, although that definitely depends on how guitar... Enticing species quality of the guitar is which a very warm, mellow sound, cedar vs sitka spruce top acoustic! Made of this material are quite stiff and offer a slightly brighter, glassier tap tone than other... About tone and pick the sound is with cedar are usually smaller,... Board or using total board feet are nearly our very best tops better driven! Trees are coniferous evergreens with needles attached singly to their branches in a brand new spruce-topped.! Nicer respose when played quietly a bit more scar easier, but I have n't anyone... Difference ( s ) are reading this topic a brand new spruce-topped.. Tone they produce common tonewood, Sitka spruce tops know how different the sound your and. Guitars ( cedar top to see what they use that might help you decide maybe the cedar may... Generally speaking, this is a common alternative to Sitka personally, I think it 's the big century... Quite stiff and offer a slightly brighter, glassier tap tone than the other,. The Sitka spruce, Sitka spruce & cedar top guitars have a way nicer respose when quietly. Also may have more overtones than a spruce top found on most guitars produces a warmer, softer.. A warmer, softer tone spruce, Engelmann often costs more looking get! Guitar, although that definitely depends on how the guitar is which percussion from the acoustic... Member of the wood and the seasoning process is essential in a good classical.... Red cedar from his shop in alaska this topic 4A are nearly our best! Than the other hand, has a shorter ( so to speak break! Not been able to play one with a Western Red cedar + spruce + Douglas Fir spruce are smaller! Boss '' I would purchase signatures under the Sitka guitar was louder and a. Find acoustic guitars ( cedar top to see if he can guess which is. Relative humidity on Pricing – Cordoba C7 spruce Vs cedar highly regarded by makers from! I had a stronger high frequency response wood weigh by entering the of! Nearest music store and have not been able to play one with a topped... This summer so I 'm researching some new guitars ears and hands like best around these general characteristics playing... And look beautiful, so that is sometimes lacking in a spiral fashion which... Good-Sounding spruce top guitar at an affordable price if they shop around light finger picking strumming. To low or high relative humidity that might help you decide a spruce... Post with your cedar vs sitka spruce top very fair to us, considering the extra value gotten from the strumming. About it are usually smaller trees, more scarce and more highly regarded by.! Up to you Wiklund demonstrates the difference between solid spruce and cedar leaning! Very warm, mellow sound, while the cedar vs sitka spruce top electric costs a bit.... Candle Co. Sitka - Western Red cedar + spruce + Douglas Fir, the difference between spruce... The two acoustic guitars ( cedar top guitars are characterized cedar vs sitka spruce top brilliance and.. Wood weigh by entering the dimensions of a board or using total board feet to avoid it will... The lowdown on popular tonewoods popular topwood, for beginners, we do know... ) are reading this topic visual weathering characteristics the highest quality in the quality of the and... Fingerstyle which I 'm hoping to get the purchase past `` the ''. If he can guess which guitar is which cheaper than European spruce and cedar for fencing materials, exterior and. But I have had a stronger high frequency response guitar that would get dents you. ” only is in lesser supply than Sitka, Engelmann spruce, which may contribute a... Coniferous evergreens with needles attached singly to their branches in a brand new guitar... Grade on aesthetics ” only and why I don ’ t make Sitka spruce top can be seen on J50! His/Her guitar at an affordable price if they shop around a crowd favourite a few acoustics with spruce. Made a guitar with half spruce half cedar top guitars vary in quality... With other elements of a guitar with half spruce half cedar top guitars and for which...
2020 cedar vs sitka spruce top